Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources
Introduction
The programme “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources” addresses a practical task within Policy Development and Impact Assessment. Training draws on the public problem, data, stakeholders and alternatives and uses techniques for developing intervention logic, comparing alternatives and designing evaluation to link the analysis to a traceable decision and action.
The participant develops an intervention memorandum and evaluation plan over 5 training days, then tests it in a practical case on “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources” involving insufficient evidence, an unintended impact or a conflict of interest. The output is reviewed against evidence quality, coherent intervention logic and measurable impact and the next step for applying it in the workplace is identified.
Objectives
By the end of the programme, participants work towards the following:
- Define the scope of Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources and the requirements for completing the task.
- Prepare and check the practical exercise inputs using the public problem, data, stakeholders and alternatives.
- Apply the following method: developing intervention logic, comparing alternatives and designing evaluation to produce an intervention memorandum and evaluation plan.
- Test the outcome in the event of insufficient evidence, an unintended impact or a conflict of interest and document the correction.
- Present and assess the output using evidence quality, coherent intervention logic and measurable impact and define an implementation plan.
Programme topics
Day 1: Defining the scope of the exercise and completion requirements
- Translate the programme title “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources” into a task, a defined scope and a reviewable output
- Define the problem, target group and expected outcome
- Identify the data and stakeholders required from the public problem, data, stakeholders and alternatives
Day 2: Preparing data and evidence and establishing a baseline
- Prepare case data for “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources” and check its completeness and consistency
- Document assumptions and the source of each input in an intervention memorandum and evaluation plan
- Identify the gap between the current situation and the target outcome using evidence quality, coherent intervention logic and measurable impact
Day 3: Developing the solution and carrying out the specialist task
- Compare alternatives and identify assumptions
- Produce the first version of an intervention memorandum and evaluation plan to support “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources”
- Link each result to its source using developing intervention logic, comparing alternatives and designing evaluation
Day 4: Testing alternatives and exceptions and reviewing the output
- Complete a practical case on “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources” involving insufficient evidence, an unintended impact or a conflict of interest
- Design a measurement framework for intended and unintended impacts
- Record discrepancies, errors, validity limits and corrective decisions in an intervention memorandum and evaluation plan
Day 5: Presenting the practical output and workplace transfer plan
- Present an intervention memorandum and evaluation plan resulting from “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources” and review it with the training group
- Measure completion of the practical exercise using evidence quality, coherent intervention logic and measurable impact and trace the evidence
- Develop an implementation plan specifying the responsible person, deadline, approval decision and outcome monitoring mechanism
Outputs
- an intervention memorandum and evaluation plan tailored to the subject of “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources”, with traceability of data, assumptions and decisions.
- Results of testing a practical case on “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources” involving insufficient evidence, an unintended impact or a conflict of interest, with documented findings and how they were addressed.
- An implementation plan that measures evidence quality, coherent intervention logic and measurable impact and identifies the responsible person, deadline and review mechanism.
Who should attend
- Policy analysts, planning and evaluation teams and public decision makers
- Team members assigned to implement or review “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources” whose responsibilities relate to Policy Development and Impact Assessment.
Participation requirements and delivery methodology
- Experience or a work assignment related to Policy Development and Impact Assessment that enables participation in practical exercises and discussion of alternatives.
- Training and hypothetical data are used. Personal data and confidential documents are excluded from classroom exercises.
- Practical workshops, evidence reviews and case simulations addressing Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources, with the output developed progressively throughout the programme.
- The output is assessed for completeness, consistency of sources and its ability to measure evidence quality, coherent intervention logic and measurable impact.
Conclusion
The programme “Analysis of alternatives to government intervention and comparison of their effects and resources” concludes with a presentation of an intervention memorandum and evaluation plan and an explanation of the underlying evidence, decisions and alternatives. Application limits and outstanding findings are recorded and converted into a follow-up plan with a responsible person, a deadline and a clear measure.
