Making Executive Decisions when Evidence Conflicts and Information Is Incomplete
Introduction
The programme “Making Executive Decisions when Evidence Conflicts and Information Is Incomplete” focuses on a specific practical need within Executive Leadership and Team Management. The course begins with Formulation of the issue and separation of facts from assumptions and its exercises progress through to Simulation of new information and revision of the resolution.
The participant works on a training case linked to the subject of the programme to produce: a decision note containing alternatives, criteria, counter-cludes, limits of trust and review requirements. Alternatives, limitations and decision guides are reviewed and the results are then adapted to the authority and policies of the entity before they are applied.
Objectives
By the end of the programme, participants work towards the following in a practical case:
- Formulation of the issue and separation of facts from assumptions
- Analysis of the quality of evidence and possible biases
- Comparison of alternatives and sensitivity testing
- Conduct of an organized protest and decision-making session
- Simulation of new information and revision of the resolution
Programme topics
Day 1: Formulation of the issue and separation of facts from assumptions
- Identification of the recipient of the communication, the decision requested and the facts supporting the recommendation.
- Review the clarity of the wording and consistency of the figures and highlight what needs to be answered or adopted.
Day 2: Analysis of the quality of evidence and possible biases
- Define acceptance criteria for the output and collect evidence of the gap rather than relying on impressions.
- Distinguish addressing symptoms from addressing causes and select evidence to verify prevention of recurrence.
Day 3: Comparison of alternatives and sensitivity testing
A practical exercise tailored to this day’s topic: Comparison of alternatives and sensitivity testing.
Day 4: Conduct of an organized protest and decision-making session
- The decision required shall be distinguished from the missing information and the authority to adopt it.
- Comparison of alternatives and recording of justification and responsibility and subsequent review of the decision.
Day 5: Simulation of new information and revision of the resolution
A practical exercise tailored to this day’s topic: Simulation of new information and revision of the resolution.
Outputs
- Decision note containing alternatives, criteria, counter-proofing, limits of trust and review requirements
- A documented practical portfolio covering the programme topics, including decisions, evidence and limitations of use.
- A workplace transfer plan identifying the person responsible for the next step, a trial date and a criterion for verifying the outcome.
Who should attend
- Members of the leadership teams and decision committees
- Team members assigned to prepare or review the outputs specified in the programme topics, according to their experience and roles.
Participation requirements and delivery methodology
- Experience or a work assignment related to Executive Leadership and Team Management, with programme suitability reviewed with the Training Department.
- Hypothetical data and cases are used. Disclosure of personal data or confidential documents is not required.
- Exercises, practical cases, discussion of alternatives and review of the practical output, based on each training day’s topic.
- The output is assessed for completeness, fitness for purpose and practicality. Specialist aspects are reviewed by authorized professionals.
Conclusion
The programme concludes with presentation and review of the practical output and a link between the next step and the participant’s workplace. The focus is on Simulation of new information and revision of the resolution and documenting what requires amendment or approval before actual implementation.
